BRPierce ( talk) 20:16, 11 August 2010 (UTC) Addendum: while, as I said, I wish to avoid an edit war, and am attempting to comply with WP:AGF, it is difficult to interpret edits such as in a constructive fashion. I asked that the editor making the changes please discuss them here on the talk page, but have received no response rather than get into an edit war, I asked for a third opinion. Finally, I think that the changes being inserted overstate the importance of Outlaw Press and James Shipman by my count, Outlaw Press receives more mentions in the current version of the article than Flying Buffalo, the company that actually produces the game. If FBInc's position on this has changed in the last year or so, that's great, but it needs to be sourced. Second, certain of the claims are contradicted by official sources for example, Rick Loomis of FBInc has repeatedly stated that there was no official sixth edition of Tunnels and Trolls. First, sourced statements are being removed. BRPierce ( talk) 17:30, 11 August 2010 (UTC) The changes being implemented by the anonymous editor concern me for a number of reasons covered above. BRPierce ( talk) 15:34, 11 August 2010 (UTC)Īs the changes have been reinserted without discussion, and in the interests of avoiding WP:3RR, I have filed a request for a third opinion on these changes. If the editor making these claims can provide sources for them, it would be greatly appreciated. The edits contained factually-inaccurate assertions (for instance, claiming that the 6th edition published by Outlaw Press was official, a claim flatly contradicted by Flying Buffalo on numerous occasions.) While this may be true, it borders on an accusation of plagiarism, and as such, needs to be well-sourced.Ĥ. The edits contained numerous unsourced assertions, such as the claim that the rules of T&T were taken wholesale from D&D. The edits seemed to represent a violation of NPOV, removing mention of the (well-sourced) controversy concerning Outlaw Press and inserting (unsourced) positive commentary on Outlaw Press.ģ. Neither Outlaw Press nor Jim Shipman are particularly major contributors to T&T's development as a game as such, they do not need to be mentioned in every section of the article.Ģ. I've reverted several edits by an anonymous editor. To assist with the process, editors are requested to summarize the dispute in a short sentence below.
inspired the Fighting Fantasy books and that the Corgi editions were an attempt by that publisher to break into the FF market in the UK by obtaining a licence from FBI to take advantage of the ready source of material. I believe that the original solo books Buffalo Castle etc.
Tunnels and trolls 7.5 pdf download series#
"Corgi Books in the United Kingdom produced mass-market paperback-sized versions of the core rulebook as well as many of the solo adventures (occasionally with adult content removed), a format which paved the way for the renowned Fighting Fantasy series of gamebooks."
I have a problem with this statement as written in the History section:
0 kommentar(er)
